Why Measuring Marketing ROI is a Hurdle for US Law Firms and How to Overcome It

Why Measuring Marketing ROI is a Hurdle for US Law Firms and How to Overcome It

Measuring the Marketing ROI of any marketing strategy will inform the decision behind a future marketing investment and marketing campaign.

In today’s rapidly evolving digital landscape, effective marketing has become a critical component of success for law firms. The strategic deployment of resources to reach prospective clients and generate leads is no longer a luxury, but a necessity. However, it’s not enough to merely invest in marketing efforts; law firms must also understand the Return On Investment (ROI) they are achieving. This knowledge is paramount for informing future strategies on marketing spend and guiding law firms toward the most cost-effective and impactful marketing campaigns and initiatives.

Despite its importance, measuring marketing ROI presents a significant challenge for many US law firms. Understanding these difficulties and learning how to overcome them can give your firm a competitive edge.

In this blog, we will explore why measuring marketing ROI is often a hurdle for law firms and provide practical solutions to help you navigate these challenges. Whether you are a small practice looking to grow or a well-established firm seeking to maximize your marketing efficiency, this guide offers insights to help you make informed, data-driven decisions.

The Importance of Measuring Marketing ROI for Law Firms

Marketing ROI, or Return on Investment, is a critical metric that quantifies the financial benefits an organization receives from its marketing tactics and efforts in relation to the costs of those efforts. In simpler terms, it is the practice of evaluating whether your marketing campaigns are generating enough business to justify the money you are spending on them.

Why is This Metric so Important for Law Firms?

Calculating ROI percentages and understanding these figures can have far-reaching benefits for any business. Here are a few:

  • They Lead to Better Financial Decisions

Firstly, understanding your marketing ROI helps your firm make better financial decisions. Marketing strategies aren’t free, and they can often account for a considerable chunk of your firm’s budget. By measuring the ROI of different campaigns, you can discern which efforts are delivering the most bang for your buck and which ones may need to be adjusted or even abandoned. If you end up with a negative ROI, the project is harder to justify on financial terms. This kind of analysis can lead to significant cost savings.

  • They Lead to Better Resource Allocation

Secondly, calculating your marketing ROI aids in resource allocation. Once you can identify the marketing channels that generate the highest ROI, you can funnel more resources into those areas and less into underperforming ones. Therefore, calculating marketing ROI not only optimizes your marketing budget but can also help your firm achieve better results.

  • They Lead to Better Business Strategy

Lastly, effective measurement of marketing ROI can greatly enhance decision-making at strategic levels. By providing clear insights into what’s working and what’s not, ROI data can guide your law firm’s marketing strategy, helping you to adjust your approach, experiment with new marketing tactics, or double down on successful ones.

Measuring ROI includes all marketing spend from measuring digital marketing ROI to the costs of social media marketing and management, customer relationship management, ad spend and any digital marketing campaigns.

The task of accurately measuring marketing ROI may seem daunting for law firms, particularly those without a dedicated marketing team or without a strong background in data analysis. However, this challenge is surmountable, and the benefits are too significant to ignore.

Why is Measuring Marketing ROI a Hurdle for US Law Firms?

Understanding the challenges faced by law firms when calculating marketing ROI is the first step towards overcoming them. Here are some of the most common hurdles:

  1. Difficulties in Tracking and Attribution

    One major challenge is tracking the effectiveness of various marketing efforts and correctly attributing client acquisition to specific marketing campaigns. Unlike retail businesses where a direct relationship between marketing and purchase can often be seen, law firms typically have multiple touchpoints with potential clients before they engage the firm’s services. Thus, attributing a new client to a specific marketing campaign can be complex and often ambiguous.

  2. Long Client Conversion Cycles

    Law firms typically have a longer sales cycle compared to many other industries. The time between a potential client’s initial contact with the firm and when they become a paying client can be extensive. This long conversion cycle can make it challenging to measure marketing ROI in the short term and requires patience and diligent tracking. But marketing does more for a company than generate profits in the short term; it also builds lasting value and drives future profits. This is where the concept of customer lifetime value can be useful. By calculating how much one customer is worth in comparison with others, marketers can show the impact of marketing spend over the course of the company’s ongoing relationship with that customer.

  3. Quantifying Intangible Benefits

    Some benefits derived from marketing efforts, such as brand awareness and improved reputation, are challenging to quantify. While these factors are essential and can lead to client acquisition in the long term, their impact is often indirect and hard to measure, making the ROI calculation process more complex.

  4. Limited Technical Knowledge or Resources

    For many law firms, particularly smaller ones, there may be a lack of knowledge or resources needed to properly track and analyze marketing ROI. This includes not only understanding how to calculate ROI but also how to use analytical tools to gather necessary data.

Many marketing analysts suggest that a good marketing ROI should be at least a 5:1 ratio. An exceptional ROI would be a 10:1 ratio, and a poor ROI would be a 2:1 ratio or lower.

In the face of these challenges, it might be tempting for law firms to eschew the complexities of ROI measurement. However, the benefits of understanding your firm’s marketing ROI far outweigh some of these challenges.

How to Overcome These Hurdles

Despite the challenges, it is possible for law firms to accurately measure their marketing ROI. Here are some strategies to consider:

  1. Implementing Proper Tracking Tools

    Leveraging analytical and Customer Relationship Management (CRM) tools can help law firms track leads, conversions, and customer interactions. These tools can provide data on how potential clients are interacting with your firm’s marketing efforts and when they convert into paying clients. By properly utilizing these tools, firms can gain insights into which marketing efforts are most effective.

  2. Adopting Attribution Models

    To calculate marketing ROI, attribution models can be utilized to assign credit to different marketing channels involved in a client’s journey, be it through digital marketing strategies, direct mail, print advertising, speaking engagements, sponsorships, public relations and more. These models can help you understand which touchpoints or actions led a potential client to engage in your services. Multi-channel attribution models can be especially useful, allowing you to distribute credit across several touchpoints.

  3. Patience and Persistence:

    Recognize that the legal sector often involves long client conversion cycles. It may take several months, or even years, to see the full results of some marketing efforts. Therefore, it is essential to have patience and track metrics consistently over an extended period of time to accurately calculate marketing ROI.

  4. Quantifying Intangibles:

    Although it is challenging to measure intangible benefits like brand awareness and reputation, it’s not impossible. Consider indirect methods and marketing activities like surveys or interviews to assess brand perception, or track metrics like website traffic, social media followers, and content engagement to understand brand awareness.

  5. Education and External Help:

    If your law firm lacks the necessary technical knowledge to measure ROI effectively, consider investing in training or workshops. Alternatively, partnering with a marketing agency specializing in law firms can provide the expertise you need. These professionals can help you implement tracking systems, understand your data, and improve your marketing strategies based on ROI.

Whether you need to run a digital marketing campaign, manage social media channels, measure your digital marketing success, calculate your email marketing ROI or apply the marketing ROI formula to your marketing expenses, we at Conroy Creative Counsel can help with it all.

Overcoming these hurdles may not happen overnight, but implementing these strategies can put your firm on the path towards better understanding your marketing ROI and ultimately lead to more effective and efficient marketing strategies that benefit your marketing performance, profit and revenue growth figures.

How Conroy Creative Counsel Can Help Your Law Firm

At Conroy Creative Counsel, we understand the unique challenges that law firms face when it comes to marketing and measuring ROI. Our expertise lies in helping law firms navigate these complexities and achieve their strategic goals. Here’s how we can assist your law firm:

  1. Strategic Planning: We will work with you to create a comprehensive marketing plan that aligns with your law firm’s goals. Our strategies are built on industry knowledge and tailored to your specific needs.
  2. Implementation of Tracking Systems: We can help your firm set up and utilize the most effective analytical and CRM (Customer Relationship Management) tools. These systems will enable you to track leads and conversions, providing the data necessary to measure your marketing ROI accurately.
  3. Attribution Modeling: Our team can guide your firm in adopting effective attribution models that provide insights into the client’s journey and highlight the most impactful marketing strategy based on solid data.
  4. ROI Calculation and Analysis: We specialize in calculating marketing ROI and analyzing the results. We will break down the data into understandable insights and provide actionable recommendations to enhance your marketing strategies and advise your firm’s marketing spending.
  5. Education and Training: We believe in empowering our clients. Our team is available to provide training and education on ROI measurement, ensuring that your firm has a clear understanding of how your marketing efforts are performing and what marketing investments make the most sense in your scenario.
  6. Brand Development: We will help your firm quantify the intangibles. From surveys to monitor brand perception, to strategies that boost online engagement and improve your brand’s visibility, we will ensure your firm’s reputation is being effectively managed and measured.

From marketing cost, to key performance indicators, search engine optimization, Google Analytics, ad spend, content marketing efforts, mapping customer journey through a marketing channel, we at Conroy Creative Counsel can do it all.

At Conroy Creative Counsel, we are committed to driving success for your law firm. We understand the challenges law firms face and we know that every firm is unique, and that is why we offer customized solutions to meet our clients’ specific needs.

Contact Us Today

Understanding and accurately measuring your marketing ROI is essential to the long-term success and growth of your law firm. If you are struggling with this crucial aspect of your marketing strategy, it is time to take action.

Start by assessing your current ROI measurement strategies. Are you using the right tools? Are you considering all relevant metrics, including the intangibles? If you are finding it difficult to answer these questions or implement efficient tracking systems, consider seeking expert assistance.

At Conroy Creative Counsel, we specialize in helping law firms like yours navigate the complex world of marketing ROI. Our team can provide you with the necessary tools, guidance, and expertise to accurately measure your marketing efforts and optimize your strategies based on data-driven insights.

Don’t let the challenges of measuring marketing ROI hinder the growth of your law firm. Contact us today to learn more about how we can help you overcome these hurdles and set your firm on the path to continued success.


I'm Karin Conroy

Founder of Conroy Creative Counsel, an award-winning recognized leader that has cracked the code of smart, sophisticated, and strategic marketing for law firms.

Browse by Category

case study


How we built our client’s websites to convey their message and deliver impact and measurable results for their law firms.


© – Content and images in this blog are copyright Conroy Creative Counsel unless stated otherwise. Feel free to repost or share images for non-commercial purpose, but please make sure to link back to this website and its original post.

Make evidence based decisions about marketing.

Discover the RIGHT marketing budget for your firm's goals.